Skip to Content

Why Do Soccer Teams Loan Players?

Players change teams in every major sport around the world. While it is inevitable to see players jump from squad to squad occasionally, soccer is a bit different and one option they have which is referred to as a loan.

Why do soccer teams loan players? Soccer teams loan players that need the experience in a lower level to take the next step in their career and eventually comeback and be ready for a place in the starting 11. Loans also occur as an alternative to a transfer or because a player in unhappy and wants a change of scenery.

History of Loan System in Soccer

It’s a bit of a blast from the past, but the loan system hasn’t always been a part of soccer. Over time, however, clubs recognized the need for flexibility. At its core, the loan system was born out of practicality. In the early days, it was all about player development. A young prodigy stuck in a top team’s reserve might never get the chance to dazzle on the main stage. And what a waste that would be! So, out went these young guns, temporarily, to lesser-known clubs to gain experience. Soon, this practice became codified, and its use expanded beyond just youngsters.

Loaning Young Prospects Out

There are only 11 spots on the field at any one time, which means that some young players do not get the meaningful minutes that they are hoping for on a major club. These teams do not want to give up this talented player just yet, so they send the young prospects out on loan to get more time.

This invaluable time playing in meaningful matches can really help a player start to develop more quickly. It is one thing to practice with the top team, but without real match experience, players can become very stagnant with their growth.

Some of the top teams around the world have an arrangement with clubs in lesser leagues that can help with these type of loans. As one example, Manchester United works directly with Royal  Antwerp. This makes the loan process even easier, and players can easily return back to the main team if they are needed.

In other professional leagues, especially in North America, there is a minor-league system that works in a somewhat similar fashion. If a baseball player is not getting consistent playing time, they can be sent down to the minor leagues to get those appearances. Once they are ready to go, they can move back up to the major league team.

Loans occasionally occur when a younger player is exceeding expectations as well. A bigger club might want to loan a player and try them out to see if they can contribute. It is also a way to test a player out before handing out a bigger contract.

Loan Rules and Regulations Across Leagues

Diving into the nitty-gritty of loans, it’s interesting to see how different leagues have varied rules and regulations. For instance:

  • Premier League: They’ve put a cap on short-term and season-long loans. But here’s a twist! There’s no limit on players loaned out to foreign clubs.
  • La Liga: The Spanish league allows only one player to be loaned from another La Liga side, with restrictions on playing against parent clubs. Neat, right?
  • Serie A: Italy’s top league permits two players from a single club. But again, they can’t face their parent team. Sounds fair.
  • Bundesliga: Their system is a tad more liberal. German teams can loan as many players as they want without any age restrictions.

Honestly, it’s a bit of a jigsaw puzzle, but it’s fun to see how each league tries to carve out its niche.

Keeping Veterans Fit

Loans are not just restricted to young players, as some veterans will have an opportunity to be loaned out to another team to get some experience as well. For example, maybe a player is trying to bounce back from a small injury, and they are not quite ready to play for the main team.

When that is the case, they can be loaned out to a team in a lesser league, gain their footing, and then show that they are ready to play meaningful minutes back with their original club.

Teams will also loan out veterans who might not fit in a certain system. Teams will change systems from time to time, especially if there is a coaching change. If those players are still on the squad, it makes sense to have them loaned out instead of just wasting time on the sidelines.

Helping Out a Frustrated Player

With so many lineup limits in soccer, it is inevitable that at least a few players are going to be frustrated with playing time every single year. When that is the case, a loan opportunity is there, and it can sometimes be used to make the best of a bad situation.

Players who become very frustrated with their role on the team might start to negatively affect how things are going on a day-to-day basis. It is better to loan out the player to a team that they might be able to help out, instead of letting them become a fool in the locker room. It is not exactly an ideal situation for anyone involved, but it is generally considered a positive in the end considering the options.

What Are The Financial Ramifications of a Loan Player?

The tricky thing for a lot of fans to figure out is how financials work with a loaned player. Unlike a transfer, teams that are receiving a loaned player do not have to pay that team. They are only responsible for the player salary when they are on loan, and even that can be covered by bigger teams if there is an arrangement.

This is one of the reasons why a loan is sometimes a better option than going through with a transfer. Teams do not necessarily have the money to do transfers the way they would like to, so a loan is a cheaper alternative to get a player who can also contribute.

They are also transfer windows that teams must abide by if they are trying to get new talent. Outside of the transfer windows, a team might only be limited to loan opportunities.

Comparison: Loans vs. Permanent Transfers

Let’s break this down:

  • Commitment: A loan is like dating. You’re not really committed. Permanent transfers, on the other hand, are like marriages. There’s paperwork, and it’s meant to last.
  • Cost: Loans can be cheaper. Teams don’t always have to pay a transfer fee. But with permanent transfers? Ka-ching! Big bucks involved.
  • Flexibility: Loans provide a chance to ‘try before you buy’. If a player’s not jelling, back he goes. No harm, no foul.
  • Contractual Obligations: With transfers, the player’s old contract is terminated. A new one begins. But with loans? It’s like hitting pause and then play again.

How Do Players React To Being On Loan?

There really is no general answer to how players feel when they are loaned out to another team. Some players are beyond frustrated with their lack of playing time on one team, so they view it as a fresh start. Maybe they have an opportunity to prove themselves to get a look at a contract on the road, and that is always motivational.

There are other players who just become more frustrated when they are loaned out to another team, because they might feel like they are being demoted without much of a chance to show what they can do. This can be a tricky situation for the team accepting a loan, because their roster might suffer despite adding a talented player.

Much like any transaction, there are success stories, and there are complete disasters. In recent memory, one very successful loan that was also extremely expensive was Killian Mbappe going from AS Monaco to Paris St. Germain. The deal was worth 45,000,000 pounds, but it led to a permanent deal that looks like it could last for a very long time. Mbappe is looking like an all-time great, and he has made the team that much better.

Why Loans Are Here To Stay

Not everyone is a huge fan of loans and soccer, but they are part of the business side of the sport. Teams can swing their season around by making the right moves with loans. They may not always make sense to fans in the beginning, but some of them end up making a major change for the better that leads to a ton of success.

Notable Successful and Unsuccessful Loans

Every coin has two sides. So does the loan system. Let’s get into some highs and lows:

Success Stories:

  • Carlos Tevez to West Ham: From obscurity to stardom, Tevez’s loan move saved West Ham from relegation and made him a Premier League sensation.
  • Romelu Lukaku to West Brom: This lad scored 17 goals during his loan spell, paving his way to become one of the Premier League’s best strikers.
  • Thibaut Courtois to Atletico Madrid: Loaned from Chelsea, he blossomed into one of the world’s top goalkeepers.

Oh, the Disasters:

  • Radamel Falcao to Manchester United & Chelsea: Once a prolific scorer, Falcao’s Premier League loan stints were, well, underwhelming.
  • Andy Carroll to Liverpool: A loan move turned permanent, but injuries and form made it a regrettable deal.
  • Kim Kallstrom to Arsenal: Signed as an emergency loan, he arrived injured. Not the best start, right?